Socyberty > History

Would History Have Been Different?

Have you ever thought if history would have been different if some shapers of world history continued in the professions they were trained rather than go and change world history?

You had to remember lists of kings and queens, dates when certain battles were won and which famous person did what. Basically official history teaching is still pretty similar. The role of key individuals as shapers of history still remains central in history teaching.

If you looked carefully at the lives of most such shapers of history, you would notice that at some point in their lives they changed their professions. They had been trained in some trade or profession, usually the same as their forefathers, but something made them abandon this. As if they suddenly started hearing the call of a distant drummer and they responded.

Have you ever thought what would have happened if these history shapers would not have responded and continued in the professions they were trained in rather than go about changing history. Think of these formidable individuals: Jesus, the Prophet Muhammad, Christopher Columbus, Adolf Hitler, Stalin, and Mao Tse Tung.

Jesus

Jesus (we're considering his profession only and not whether he was son of God or not) was a Jewish carpenter by training. What would have happened if he had continued in the business of making doors, windows, and furniture rather than founding Christianity?

Prophet Muhammad

Then take the Prophet Muhammad, who was a merchant by profession. How would the world have developed if he'd continued in that line? Would he have ended up creating the global WalMart of his days rather than found a major religion and supervise its phenomenal spread?

Christopher Columbus

How would the world have changed if Columbus, a trader had continued trading and not discovered America? Would we be conversing in Maya, Inca, or Native American languages instead of English or Spanish?

Adolf Hitler

Would the Second World War have not started if Hitler, a postcard painter had sold his paintings well and retired rich to a life of indolent luxury near Lake Constance?

Joseph Stalin

If Stalin had persevered in his theological studies and indeed spent his entire life as a priest: Would that have changed world history?

Mao Tse Tung

What kind of a librarian Mao Tse Tung would have been? Would his spending his life in a secure government job as a librarian all his life have shaped world events very differently?

39
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
Teaching History Through the Movies  |  If Only Adolf Hitler Had Become an Artist
More Articles by Rana Sinha
Can Altruism Save Humans From Becoming Extinct?  |  Should You Drop the F-Bomb?
Latest Articles in History
Lord Mayors of London  |  Mary, Queen of Peace
Comments (7)
#1 by nobert soloria bermosa, Apr 23, 2008
nice article, well if they didn't, others will, except for Jesus because it had been prophesied long before He was born that He'll do the things he did.
one point,it wasn't actually Columbus who discovered the Americas,there were several other European(like the Vikings) who have reach the place long before he did.although colonization might have happened later.
we can only presume,but we can't turn back the clock
thanks for the read,
#2 by Ainu Auvoinen, Apr 23, 2008
All these "great"people you mentioned were selected to be born for their destinies.They would have changed the world order even had they chosen any other sphere to function. Some one somewhere up there in the clouds is playing jigsaw puzzle with us mortals and having great fun."Now, whom shall I select to discover that distant America,let us see, there goes one Columbus, why not take him for the job". And when there were too many people inhabiting Europe, the Player got one stalin and one hitler to do the job".
#3 by Ainu Auvoinen, Apr 23, 2008
All these "great"people you mentioned were selected to be born for their destinies.They would have changed the world order even had they chosen any other sphere to function. Some one somewhere up there in the clouds is playing jigsaw puzzle with us mortals and having great fun."Now, whom shall I select to discover that distant America,let us see, there goes one Columbus, why not take him for the job". And when there were too many people inhabiting Europe, the Player got one stalin and one hitler to do the job".
#4 by Johanna, Jun 14, 2008
I wonder how these 'great' people would interpret this article? Interesting article.
#5 by Lee Song Ping, Jun 19, 2008
Had a good laugh thining of Chairman Mao as a retired librarian.
#6 by Lee Song PIng, Jun 20, 2008
I mean thinking..
#7 by Varpu, Jun 21, 2008
Interesting questions and viewpoint.
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Inside Socyberty

Activism

 /

Advice

 /

Crime

 /

Death

 /

Disabled

 /

Economics

 /

Education

 /

Ethnicity

 /

Folklore

 /

Future

 /

Gay & Lesbians

 /

Government

 /

History

 /

Holidays

 /

Issues

 /

Languages

 /

Law

 /

Lifestyle Choices

 /

Men

 /

Military

 /

Organizations

 /

Paranormal

 /

People

 /

Philanthropy

 /

Philosophy

 /

Politics

 /

Psychology

 /

Relationships

 /

Religion

 /

Sexuality

 /

Social Sciences

 /

Society

 /

Sociology

 /

Spirituality

 /

Subcultures

 /

Support Groups

 /

Work


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Socyberty
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.